Pencheff & Fraley Co., LPA Injury and Accident Attorneys logo

Pencheff & Fraley Co., LPA Injury and Accident Attorneys

Call (614) 224-4114
Contact us today
for a consultation

Ontario, Ohio accident & injury law firm

Workers' Compensation, Social Security , Personal Injury law, Auto accidents law, Car accidents, medical malpractice attorney

Welcome to Pencheff & Fraley Co., LPA Injury and Accident Attorneys in Ontario Ohio. We are a comprehensive Ohio law firm, primarily focused in the areas of Personal Injury, Workers’ Compensation, and Social Security. Our attorneys have vast experience in aggressively pursuing settlement as well as obtaining favorable trial verdicts. Injured in a car, truck, or motorcycle accident? We will fight for you! Employer not paying out in your workers’ compensation claim? We will fight for you! Social Security benefits denied? We will fight for you! At Pencheff and Fraley, The Client Comes First! Are you looking for an auto accident attorney in Ontario, Ohio area? Call our Mansfield personal injury attorneys to get a free case review.

Our Attorneys

Joseph Fraley Photo

Joseph Fraley

Joe graduated from Ohio Northern University and Capital University Law School in 1991 and immediately began practicing in the firm Pencheff, King, and Forman. The managing partner, Peter Pencheff, had founded the firm in 1953 solely to represent injured workers before the Industrial Commission of Ohio. After three years Joe was made partner in the firm, and expanded the areas of practice to include personal injury claims including car accidents, wrongful death, and intentional tort claims. In 2008 his firm merged with the firm of Mitchell, Allen, Catalano & Boda. In 2020 the firm changed back to Pencheff & Fraley LPA upon Bill Catalano and Dan Boda’s retirements.

Experienced Trial Lawyer
Joe has spent his career as a trial lawyer. He has extensive experience in Workers’ Compensation, Personal Injury, Intentional Tort, and Litigation, and has tried lawsuits in many Ohio Counties.

He is a member of the Ohio and Columbus Bar Associations.

Joe has fought for workers and injured persons’ rights for over 20 years. He lives in Granville and is married with three children. In his free time he enjoys golf and basketball.

  • J.D.
  • B.A.
Pencheff & Fraley Co., LPA Injury and Accident Att
33 Lexington-Springmill Rd S, Ontario, OH 44906, USA
(614) 224-4114
Help & Feedback